When I read Haruki Murakami’s A Wild Sheep Chase novel I definitively
wasn’t expecting it. Anything. I wasn’t expecting any of it. And not in the
sense of there being a lot of plot twists. I mean more of its general structure
and tone. It got to the point where if something generally weird or out of place happened, I would just accept it fully, without questioning the logic of
it. It’s almost like the book has a world with its own set of rules that don’t
need to be questioned. But, I’m getting ahead of myself. In terms of my initial
reaction to the book, it was hard for me to grab on to the structure of the
story. I was halfway through the book before I realized that the Inciting
Incident hadn’t even happened yet! It had a passive protagonist who just got
dragged into whatever was happening, he had no ambitions, no real goals.
Everything about it was breaking the basic storytelling rules that we’ve been
learning about, and are commonplace in the west in order to have a “good” story. And
yet… I had a lot of fun reading it. Even considering the parts of it that were “bland”
I never felt bored. I found myself enjoying the book and getting swept away
into the world.
Comparing the story in the horror
genre against what we generally expect from a traditionally western horror
story, it’s definitively different. Japanese horror doesn’t seem to concern
itself with logic. Not everything has an explanation. Some things simply are. In
American horror, you find the pieces that let you defeat the monster. In the
Japanese tradition, you just desperately try to endure it because the forces at
play are far stronger and greater than you are. And they're not necessarily "good" or "evil." They just exist. This could be because spirits
are more deeply rooted in Japanese folklore and are a tangible part of everyday
life. There’s also a stronger element of internal conflict to heighten the
horror that isn’t just a simple instinctual conflict of “try not to get eaten
by the scary monster.” I think this adds a level of depth and is very
interesting to say the least, even if it doesn’t always follow some sort of structure. The kind of horror that this book portrays is more unsettling and surreal than the kind of stories we are used to, and I think it is very successful in that sense.
I'm glad I wasn't the only one who didn't expect anything in the book. I really like your analysis!
ReplyDelete