I was very intrigued when I first
began this book. Very quickly I noticed the odd way in which it was written. I
had thought it to be a bad editing mistake, before I read on and realized that
it was very intentional. Babel-17 by Samuel Delany is a highly philosophical
novel. This language has only third
person in it; there is no “I” or “you” used. It is also a very precise
language, each word layered with meaning. As a result, speakers of it would not
have any ability to be self-critical, or to separate reality from what the
language has programmed them to see as reality. Language mirrors ourselves, but
those same selves are absent in the language. One
of the questions raised by the novel is how much one’s language dictates the
way in which one perceives the world. Does speaking another language change the
way you think? Can one person ever truly know another?
The most important narrative thread
of Babel-17 turns out not to be the plot, which bounces us across a couple of
different planets and ships, but rather the question of whether communication
between two people is possible. That is not to say that the plot is irrelevant
or uninteresting though, the book is definitively not your stereotypical sci-fi
novel. It takes the tropes and flips them upside down, which I found very
refreshing. The hero is a telepathic Chinese woman who happens to be the most
famous poet of her age. A woman, who also has weak moments. She can talk her
way out of trouble and succeeds through using her wit and her empathy rather
than force or technology. She’s not your typical warrior and, although fights
take place, they have nothing to do with what turns out to be the hero’s
victory. There’s none of the stereotypical male dominance. The crew on Rydra’s
ship are all considered equals. The book shifts its focus away from what we’d
expect from a space adventure yarn. The ongoing war between The Alliance and
The Invaders is described not through battles but through the starvation and
horror of its impact. The fact that humans have made contact with aliens is
mentioned offhandedly in half a sentence. It just has a lot of elements that
you normally wouldn’t expect from this genre, which made this a very
interesting read.